top of page

Compassion Without Agency Is Incomplete: Teaching Our Children to Choose Health

11 minutes ago
7 min read


This past weekend, my wife Nicole and I found ourselves in a spirited Socratic debate about human behavior.

 

The subject was deceptively simple. Why do some people make meaningful changes in their lives while others, despite understanding what needs to change, remain stuck in the same unhealthy patterns?

 

After 27 years of practicing pediatrics, I have developed a theory. The words that leave our mouths reveal something profound about our capacity and readiness to change.

 

When a child or adolescent sits across from me and says, "I can't," "It's too hard," "I've tried everything," or "You don't understand my life," I hear more than frustration. I hear a narrative that may be limiting their ability to imagine a different future.

 

Nicole sees another side of the equation. She reminds me that human beings carry histories of trauma, adversity, family dysfunction, poverty, and experiences that shape their beliefs about what is possible. We cannot simply expect someone who has spent years struggling to suddenly speak confidently about changing their life.

 

She is right.

 

Years of studying Stephen Porges, Duey Freeman and Mona Delahooke and spending mornings in the newborn nursery have shown me this compassionate doorway.

 

However, it is not that simple for me. I believe there is another equally important truth.

 

Our circumstances influence us, but they do not have to define every choice we make. They, in fact, should not. And helping children discover that distinction may be one of the most important things we do as pediatricians and parents.

 

The language of change is so important. Since 2007, I have been using motivational interviewing techniques with my patients in clinical practice. This approach helps patients explore their own reasons for change rather than simply being told what to do.

 

Over the years, I have watched thousands of children and families wrestle with nutrition, physical activity, sleep, mental health, obesity, and metabolic dysfunction. One observation has remained remarkably consistent: children who begin to speak with a sense of ownership over their choices are often the ones who eventually make meaningful, lasting changes.

 

There is an important distinction between saying, "I know I should eat better," and saying, "I am going to make different choices about what I eat." The first acknowledges a problem. The second expresses an intention to act. But even that distinction is incomplete.

 

I have watched patients learn the correct language of change without possessing the internal motivation to follow through. They know what to say. They may even genuinely want a different outcome. Yet their actions remain unchanged. Conversely, I have seen children begin changing their behavior before their thinking has fully caught up. They start moving more, drinking water instead of soda, sleeping better, or changing their breakfast. Their health improves, sometimes quickly, and those improvements reinforce further action.

 

Both pathways matter.

 

In my experience, behavioral change often produces the fastest initial improvement, while a deeper shift in personal agency and language may provide the foundation for lasting success.

 

The most powerful moment occurs when a child stops asking whether change is possible and begins asking how to make it happen.

 

That is when I know something important may be shifting.

 

Here is where pediatric medicine becomes particularly complicated.

 

Children do not choose the homes into which they are born. They do not generally purchase the groceries, establish family schedules, determine household screen rules, or control the emotional environment in which they live.

 

Parents do.

 

I routinely encounter adolescents struggling with obesity, insulin resistance, poor sleep, and other metabolic problems while living in homes filled with ultra-processed foods, sugary beverages, inconsistent routines, and limited opportunities for physical activity.

 

The child is experiencing the biological consequences of an environment largely created by adults.

And yet, the child is often the person sitting in front of me being asked to change.

 

This is an enormous contradiction.

 

I address parents directly and frequently. In fact, after nearly three decades in practice, I often find that changing parental behavior is more difficult than changing the child's behavior.

 

But something fascinating happens when I turn my attention primarily toward the child.

 

Rather than discussing the child as though they are not in the room, I ask them what they want for themselves. I ask what they believe they can change. I ask them to imagine a future different from the one their current habits may be creating.

 

I treat them as someone capable of participating in the direction of their own life. And time after time, I have watched children surprise both their parents and themselves. A child may not control what food enters the home, but they may be able to choose water instead of soda. They may be able to ask for different foods, choose a different portion, move their body, or begin establishing a healthier sleep routine.

 

Not every child has the same choices available. Age, developmental capacity, family circumstances, and emotional health all matter. But the goal is to help each child recognize the choices that are available, however small they may initially seem.

 

The child is influenced by the environment, but the child is not simply the environment.

That is where agency begins.

 

Now we arrive at one of the more uncomfortable parts of this conversation. It is real. And all too common.

 

Modern parenting often places tremendous emphasis on making children happy. I understand that instinct. As parents, we love our children. We want to protect them from suffering, disappointment, frustration, and failure. But somewhere along the way, I believe we have increasingly confused immediate happiness with long-term well-being.

 

I see this play out in the examination room.

 

An adolescent describes failing to follow through on a health goal. Before we can explore what happened, a loving parent intervenes.

 

"It's okay, sweetheart. You tried."

 

Of course, it is important that children know they are loved regardless of their successes or failures.

But what happens next?

 

Does the conversation end with reassurance? Or does the parent help the child understand what went wrong and how to approach the challenge differently?

 

There is an enormous difference between compassion and enabling.

 

Compassion says, "I understand that this is difficult, and I am here to help you." Enabling says, sometimes unintentionally, "Because this is difficult, you do not need to confront it."

 

One develops resilience. The other can reinforce avoidance.

 

Modern parents settle on the latter more often to my dismay.

 

And the contradiction becomes even more striking when the same parent who excuses the child's difficulty continues purchasing the foods, providing the screens, or maintaining the household routines that undermine the child's health.

 

We cannot reasonably ask children to make difficult choices while repeatedly arranging their surroundings to make unhealthy choices the easiest ones. Love is not the elimination of discomfort. 

 

Love includes helping children develop the capacity to tolerate the discomfort necessary for growth.

 

A child can be disappointed that soda is no longer routinely available at home. A teenager can be frustrated by consistent bedtime expectations. A family can experience conflict while establishing healthier routines. None of those experiences necessarily represents a failure of parenting. Sometimes they represent parenting doing exactly what it is supposed to do.

 

Returning to my conversation with Nicole, I believe we were describing two essential parts of the same healing process. She was emphasizing the importance of understanding the person's story. I was emphasizing the importance of helping that person recognize their capacity to write the next chapter.

 

Both matter.

 

Chronic adversity, trauma, and prolonged stress can influence how people perceive themselves and their opportunities. They can affect sleep, emotional regulation, executive function, and the ability to plan for the future.

 

We should never dismiss those realities.

 

But understanding why someone feels helpless is different from accepting helplessness as their permanent identity. In fact, I would argue that genuine compassion should include helping someone discover that their history does not have to dictate every future decision.

 

This does not mean demanding positivity or pretending that real obstacles do not exist. A teenager who says, "This is really hard, but I am going to try again," may be demonstrating more meaningful agency than one who cheerfully promises to change but never acts.

 

The goal is not positive thinking for its own sake. The goal is ownership, psychological flexibility, and a willingness to act even when circumstances are imperfect. And sometimes that process takes many visits, many setbacks, and many small victories.

 

I have come to think about pediatric behavioral change through three interconnected responsibilities.

 

1) The child's responsibility: Agency

 

"My circumstances influence me, but they do not completely define my choices."

 

Children need opportunities to discover that their decisions matter. They need to experience small successes, learn from setbacks, and gradually develop confidence in their capacity to influence their health.

 

2) The parent's responsibility: Love and Structure

 

"My love requires me to provide both emotional security and developmentally appropriate structure."

 

Parents must create environments that make healthy choices accessible and sustainable. They must offer affection without abandoning boundaries, and support without removing every challenge.

 

3) The clinician's responsibility: Compassionate Accountability

 

"I will acknowledge your obstacles, but I will also help you identify and practice the choices that remain available."

 

Physicians must recognize the biological, psychological, and social realities influencing health while refusing to reduce children to passive products of those circumstances.

 

When these three responsibilities reinforce one another, the opportunity for meaningful and lasting change grows. And importantly, they do not always develop at the same time. Sometimes the parent changes first and the child follows. Sometimes a child develops the motivation to change and gradually influences the entire family. Sometimes the physician helps create the first small opening through which a different future becomes imaginable.

 

Ultimately, my goal as a pediatrician is not simply to help a child improve a laboratory value, lose excess adiposity when clinically appropriate, sleep better, or become more physically active.

 

Those outcomes matter tremendously.

But there is something even more important.

 

I want that child to become an adult who understands that they have a meaningful role in shaping their own health. An adult who can recognize adversity without surrendering to it. An adult who can experience failure without making failure an identity. An adult who can choose what is beneficial over what is immediately gratifying, not every time, but often enough to build a healthy life.

 

This is the difference between teaching a child to follow instructions and teaching a child to exercise judgment. And it may be one of the most important gifts we can give the next generation.

 

We cannot protect our children from every unhealthy influence, every disappointment, or every difficult circumstance they will encounter.

 

Nor should we try. Or want to.

 

What we can do is provide love, structure, guidance, and repeated opportunities to practice making meaningful choices.

 

We can acknowledge suffering without allowing suffering to become the entire story. We can offer compassion without surrendering accountability.

 

And we can remind our children that although they may not have chosen the circumstances in which their story began, they can increasingly participate in deciding how that story unfolds.

 

Watch the movie: I Can Only Imagine. The story can unfold as you wish it to if you choose the path despite the pain and the struggle.

 

Because the ultimate goal of parenting, and perhaps of pediatric medicine itself, is not to create children who are always happy in the moment. It is to help raise human beings capable of choosing a healthier, more resilient, and more meaningful life.

 

Until next time,

Dr. M


Comments


bottom of page